Tellers: An American Chophouse

Stepping into Tellers: An American Chophouse, you’re met with a warm and grounded energy that feels just right for both a quiet evening out or a lively gathering. Nestled on Main Street in Islip, this spot marries classic charm with a low-key sophistication, where hints of its history as a bank vault lend a unique, intimate backdrop to every visit. Whether it’s the gentle hum of conversation or the soft clinking of glasses, the pace here invites you to settle in and enjoy the moment without rush.

The atmosphere is one where thoughtful touches quietly impress — from the attentive staff who make you feel genuinely welcome, to the subtle buzz of conversation around you. Tellers draws a crowd that appreciates precision and care in their dining experience, creating a place that’s familiar yet special, where every visit can feel like a small occasion.

Food and drink at Tellers flow naturally into the experience, rather than dominate it. Expect perfectly cooked steaks that strike a simple, satisfying balance, alongside comforting sides and carefully crafted cocktails that reveal a knack for classic flavors with a slight twist. The menu mirrors the mood of the room — thoughtful but unpretentious, with dishes that invite sharing and moments of comfort, like a rich Lobster Mac & Cheese or a perfectly balanced Margarita. And those late-afternoon or weekend brunches carry the same ease, making it a place to return to, time and again.

The joy of Tellers comes less from flash and more from those human moments: a friendly nod from the server, the satisfaction of a well-made cocktail, the quiet delight in a meal that hits all the right notes without fuss. It’s a local gem where effortlessness meets care — a restaurant that understands the art of making people feel at home, whether that’s for a casual dinner, a celebratory feast, or simply a place to unwind in familiar, inviting surroundings.